Caleb has a presser on the Charter Arms Pit Bull. Its a neat idea, and as Caleb Says ” Are there better defensive revolvers out there? Certainly. Are there better defensive guns chambered in .40 S&W? Yes. But that doesn’t mean I don’t want one, I just can’t help myself.” Its a neat gun, and I haven’t handled one, so I won’t comment if its a good gun or not. Also .40 S&W is not a cartridge I have much love for. I think 9mm and .45 do just as good a job as it does, and with a more pleasant recoil.
Still I was struck by this statement from the presser:
Nick Ecker, president of Charter Arms, said, “The Pit Bull is the ideal revolver for law enforcement officers to use as their back up, because they can now carry a revolver that utilizes the same ammo as their sidearm.
Now first up, I’d say a gun in their “Undercover” size (S&W J-Frame Equivalent) that eats 9mm would make a LOT more sense for this angle, as it would be much smaller, and much lighter. As it is, this Pit Bull appears to be the same size as their famous Bulldog .44, and it has an all-steel frame, so its also heavy.
Essentially if the Officer carries a Glock 22 or 23, this “Backup Gun” is about the same size and weight as the duty gun it supports.
Now personally I could care less what I carry for a BUG, as I’ll be drawing and shooting my primary gun in things go bad, and I’ll only be going for the BUG if I run out of ammo, or my primary has a malfunction. (or to arm an unarmed comrade who I know is proficient in firearms…or has either run dry or has a malfunction).
Still I don’t put on a pistol thinking I’m going to use it (otherwise I’ll bring a rifle or a shotgun) and on that vein I don’t carry spare mags because I think I’ll run dry, and I don’t carry a BUG thinking I’ll have to go for it. But I also don’t carry a gun because I’m an optimist.
Still with all that I really don’t expect to utilize my primary ammo into my BUG…I imagine If I had time to be stripping .40 Rounds from my duty mags into a revolver I’d have time to get my primary working. Personally when I carry two guns its a 1911 and a S&W642. One’s a .45, the other is a .38. No ammo interchangeability, and the .38 is just there to hopefully end a fight my .45 couldn’t quite get me out of.
If I really was concerned about ammo interchangeability, you’d be making a much better tactical decision to pack a subcompact version of your duty gun. So if I had a Glock 22, or 23 as my duty gun, a Glock 27 is much smaller and lighter than the Pit Bull, and there’s no need to fiddle with the ammo, you can just stuff the bigger mags into the smaller gun. Same goes with the S&W M&P series, as well as the Springfield XD series, as well as the full-size 1911s vs the compact models. Don’t know Sigs too well, but I suspect the 226 and 229 can share mags. The list goes on.
Still this is all gun-geekery. Bottom line, carry your damn guns! Carry a gun you like and are familiar with. Carrying 2 guns, or a reload, or both is better than not, but don’t get too twisted about your loadout. If you find yourself going toe-to-toe with the red Army and you don’t have a long gun, and a SQUAD behind you long guns (and light machine guns) you’re fucked no matter HOW many guns you have, or what ammo they eat from.
Don’t over-think things. Just carry and be safe!